top of page

Minimum Guest Count 50 Guests


Price Plus 20% Service Charge
(which includes gratuity) & Sales Tax

*note other caterers charge a service charge
AND a gratuity charge


3% Credit Card Fee Added if paying by CC


Self Service Can Save You $$$


Tailgate To-Go Packages Available


Prices Based on 100 Guests or More


Book Early--Call for a Proposal Today!


Most Meats Grilled on Site




Free Tent or 10% Discount for Groups of 200 Guests or More!!!

Subject to Restrictions.


For over 25 years and with hundreds of thousands of satisfied customers Mr. Picnic is Wisconsin's smart choice for catering for any occasion. Count on our professionals for the finest foods and superior service with on time serving and ample quantities. We are a preferred caterer at the Milwaukee County Zoo. We are the perfect caterer for your company picnic, National Convention, wedding, pig roast, graduation party or family event. 10% discount for groups of 200 guests or more!!!


*Menu Prices for the Popular Picnic Buffets are based on groups of 100 guests or more. For smaller groups of 50-74 guests add $4 per person, for groups of 75-99 add $2 per person. Upcharges do not apply to the pig roast prices or drop off service prices. Full Service includes on-site grilling, buffet equipment and staff.

Event Picture.jpg
Meat and Cheese Tray (cold cuts)
Cheese & Sausage Tray (with crackers)
Fruit Tray
Vegetable Tray with Dip
Relish Tray (pickles, peppers, olives, etc.)
Taco Dip with Chips
Shrimp Tray
Market Price
Smoked Salmon
Market Price
Finger Sandwiches
$24 per dozen
BBQ Wings
$24 per dozen
Meatballs, in sauce
$9.99 per pound
BBQ Pork
$11.99 per pound
Beef Brisket
$18.99 per pound
Bourbon Chicken, Pulled
$11.99 per pound
Roast Turkey & Gravy
$10.99 per pound
Roast Beef & Gravy
$15.99 per pound
Hot Ham
$10.99 per pound
Rolls, Lettuce, Tomato, Condiments
$2.99 per person
Pasta, Potato, Garden, 7-Layer and Fruit Salads
Also Available
2 Feet, Serves 5-10 Guests
4 Feet, Serves 10-20 Guests
6 Feet, Serves 15-30 Guests
Turkey, Ham, Roast Beef, Club, Chipotle Turkey Wrap, Veggie, Tuna or Garden Salad
$12.99 (add $1 for less than 50, add $1 for special order)
Build Your Own Sandwich Board
$12.99 Per Person (add $1 for less than 50 guests)
Potato Salad, Pasta Salad, Coleslaw or Garden Salad
$1.00 Per Person
Macaroni and Cheese
Mashed Potatoes
Assorted Beverages
$1.50 each
Wire Chafing Rack for Hot Foods
$20.00 each
Picnic Boxed Lunch
Starts at $14.99
For Safer Catering we are offering Picnic Boxed Lunches with on-site grilling. We will grill on-site and assemble a Picnic Boxed Lunch consisting of Pulled Bourbon Chicken, BBQ Pork, Quarter Pound Hamburgers, Brats, All Beef Hot Dogs, or Veggie Burgers plus relishes and condiments, a small cup of Potato Salad or Pasta Salad, a Bag of Chips, Fruit Slice, Vegetable Slice, Cookie and disposable dinnerware packet. Priced starting at $14.99 per boxed lunch for 100 guests or more and depending on number of meats (starts at one meat choice, $1 for each additional meat choice), add $4 per person for groups 50-99. Our Budget Picnic Boxed Lunch consists of choice of either BBQ Pork or Bourbon Chicken Sandwich, bag of chips and cookie for $12.99 each. Available May-Oct. Our gourmet cold deli sandwich boxed lunches on our Office Lunch Menu are $12.99
Baked Potato Boxed Lunch
Starts at $12.99
Check out our Office Lunch Menu for more information on our Baked Potato Boxed Lunch that comes with a choice of toppings such as Bacon Bits, Chicken Tinga or vegetarian Lemon Dill Butter.
Additional Servers
$35/hour/staff member
Another option for our Safer Catering under current guidelines restricting self service buffets is additional service staff to serve each item on a buffet. Please note this will require additional buffet setups as we will only be able to serve on one side of a buffet line.
Mr. Picnic's Favorites with our Signature Bourbon Chicken, Wisconsin's Best Brats and All Beef Hot Dogs
$14.99 Adults, $7.99 Kids 3-12*
1/4# Hamburgers, Signature Pulled Bourbon Chicken, Wisconsin's Best Brats & All Beef Hot Dogs
$15.99 Adults, $8.99 Kids 3-12*
1/4# Hamburgers, Wisconsin's Best Brats & All Beef Hot Dogs
$14.99 Adults, $7.99 Kids 3-12*
Signature Pulled Bourbon Chicken, 1/4# Hamburgers & All Beef Hot Dogs
$14.99 Adults, $7.99 Kids 3-12*
BBQ PICNIC MENU of Tender As Mother's Love BBQ Pork, Signature Pulled Bourbon Chicken & All Beef Hot Dogs
$13.99 Adults, $7.99 Kids 3-12*
Beef Brisket, Pulled Bourbon Chicken & All Beef Hot Dogs
$17.99 Adults, $8.99 Kids 3-12*
BUDGET MENU of 2 Meats from Burgers, Brats, BBQ Pork, Pulled Bourbon Chicken or Hot Dogs, 2 Sides, Chips & Cookies
$11.99 Adults, $6.99 Kids 3-12*
SELF SERVICE SPECIAL-BBQ Pork and Bourbon Chicken with 2 Sides, Buns, Chips, & Cookies
$10.99 Per Person, 50 guest min.
Substitute Grilled Chicken Breast for Pulled Bourbon Chicken for $2 per person additional
50-74 Guests
$25.99 Per Person, add $3 for chicken
75-99 Guests
$21.99 Per Person, add $2 for chicken
100-149 Guests
$17.50 Per Person, add $1 for chicken
150-199 Guests
$16.50 Per Person, add $1 for chicken
200-249 Guests
$15.99 Per Person, Add $1 for chicken (10% discount)
250+ Guests
$14.99 Per Person, add $1 for chicken (10% discount)
Veggie Burgers
$2.50 each
Corn on the Cob
$2.99 ($500 minimum)
Garden Salad with Dressings
$1.50 per person
Deluxe Service*
$2.99 per person
1/3# Burgers
$ .75 Upgrade
Baked Potatoes
$2.00 Per Person
Ice Cream
$2.00 per person
Cold Soda & Water
$1.50 each
* Deluxe Service includes larger entrees, pretzel rolls, expanded condiments and buffet skirting
Gluten Free Items on Menu:
Hamburgers, Brats, Hot Dogs, BBQ Pork, Beef Brisket, Pig Roast, Potato Salad, Coleslaw, Chips, Fruit, Vegetables, Corn, Garden Salad
bottom of page